Dopo la pubblicazione di “Terra mia” del 1977 e la conferma con l’album “Omonimo” del 1979, Pino Daniele pubblica “Nero a metà” il disco che lo consacrerà definitivamente al grande pubblico. Daniele ha venticinque anni ma ha già una buona esperienza come strumentista suona, infatti, dall’età di dodici anni e ha già militato in diversi gruppi partenopei compresi i Napoli Centrale... Leggi e ascolta...
Dopo la pubblicazione di “Terra mia” del 1977 e la conferma con l’album “Omonimo” del 1979, Pino Daniele pubblica “Nero a metà” il disco che lo consacrerà definitivamente al grande pubblico. Daniele ha venticinque anni ma ha già una buona esperienza come strumentista suona, infatti, dall’età di dodici anni e ha già militato in diversi gruppi partenopei compresi i Napoli Centrale. Pino Daniele come Napoli, possiede in questo disco una doppia anima, romantica la prima, ritmica la seconda, nervose e soleggiate entrambe... silvanobottaro.it/archives/366…
Listen now on your favorite streaming service. Powered by Songlink/Odesli, an on-demand, customizable smart link service to help you share songs, albums, podcasts and more.
Tired of expensive cable packages and looking for a more flexible way to watch your favorite content? IPTV (Internet Protocol Television) services are becoming increasingly popular in 2025, offering an alternative way to stream live TV channels and on-demand content. After extensive testing, I’ve put together this guide to help you navigate the top options available today.
What Makes a Great IPTV Service?
Before diving into specific providers, let’s understand what separates the best from the rest:
Stream Quality — From standard definition to crystal-clear 8K resolution
Channel Selection — Local, international, premium, and specialty options
Device Compatibility — Works with your Firestick, smart TV, phone, or tablet
Customer Support — Responsive help when things inevitably go wrong
Fair Pricing — Transparent subscription options without hidden fees
Easy Setup — From tech novices to experts, how simple is it to get started?
Reliability — Consistent performance with minimal buffering or downtime
Top 5 IPTV Services Compared
PremIPTV — Premier IPTV Service
PremIPTV stands out with its extensive channel lineup and reliable streaming quality. Their service excels particularly for sports enthusiasts, offering comprehensive coverage of major leagues and events globally.
Strengths:
Exceptional sports coverage with minimal buffering during peak events
User-friendly interface that works seamlessly across devices
Above-average customer support with responsive live chat
Worth Considering:
Not the cheapest option, though the quality justifies the cost
Setup requires some basic technical knowledge
IPTV8K — Subscription IPTV8K
As the name suggests, IPTV8K focuses on delivering ultra-high-definition content where available. Their service is ideal for viewers with premium displays who prioritize visual quality.
Strengths:
Best-in-class streaming quality with 4K and 8K options
Impressive movie and VOD library with frequent updates
Smooth performance on high-end devices
Worth Considering:
Requires robust internet connection (minimum 50Mbps recommended)
Premium quality comes with a higher price point
8K IPTV — 8K IPTV Service
Don’t confuse this with the previous entry! 8K IPTV offers a solid middle-ground option with a good balance of quality, selection, and affordability.
Strengths:
Most budget-friendly option without major compromises
Surprisingly diverse international channel selection
Simple setup process ideal for beginners
Worth Considering:
Customer support can be slower to respond
App interface feels less polished than competitors
IPTV GSE — IPTV GSE SMART
IPTV GSE focuses on providing a seamless experience across the widest range of devices, making it perfect for households with varied tech ecosystems.
Strengths:
Most versatile device compatibility (works on practically everything)
Clean, intuitive interface that’s easy to navigate
Solid EPG (Electronic Program Guide) functionality
Worth Considering:
Stream quality can be inconsistent during peak hours
Channel organization could use improvement
IPTV — 4K LIVE IPTV
Rounding out our list is 4K LIVE IPTV, which boasts one of the largest international channel libraries available, making it ideal for multilingual households or expatriates.
Strengths:
Unmatched global channel selection with options from 100+ countries
Impressive catch-up features for missed programs
Reliable performance even on modest internet connections
Worth Considering:
Navigation can feel overwhelming due to the massive selection
Setup process is more complex than some competitors
How to Pick Your Perfect IPTV Service
Three Simple Questions to Ask Yourself:
What’s your budget? Lower-priced services like 8K IPTV offer good value, while premium options like IPTV8K provide top-tier quality at higher cost points.
What do you watch most?
Sports fanatics: Consider PremIPTV
Movie buffs: IPTV8K has you covered
International content: 4K LIVE IPTV is unbeatable
Multiple device household: IPTV GSE offers the best flexibility
What device are you using? All services work with popular options like Firestick and Android TV, but IPTV GSE stands out for supporting the widest range of devices, including some older models.
Important Safety Considerations
A quick but important PSA: When exploring IPTV services, always:
Research the provider thoroughly before subscribing
Use secure payment methods for subscriptions
Consider using a VPN for additional privacy
Be wary of services with unrealistic claims or too-good-to-be-true pricing
Understand the terms of service and content licensing arrangements
Our Verdict
Overall Best: PremIPTV delivers the most consistent overall experience with exceptional sports coverage and reliability.
Best Bang for Your Buck: 8K IPTV offers remarkable value without significant compromises.
Most Global Channels: 4K LIVE IPTV is unmatched for international content variety.
Smoothest App Experience: IPTV GSE provides the most intuitive interface across the widest range of devices.
Best Picture Quality: IPTV8K lives up to its name with stunning high-definition streaming options.
Still Unsure?
Drop your questions below — we read every comment. And if you want to stay updated on deals, new tests, and honest IPTV reviews, bookmark “Top5Providers: Best IPTV Service”. We’re here to help you stream smarter, not harder.
Top 5 Best IPTV Subscriptions for 2024 – tested and reviewed by our experts. By clicking on the product name in the list below, you can easily get updated prices, technical specs, and additional info about each product.
Remember the days of flipping through a handful of channels, settling for whatever was on? Or maybe you’re still grappling with endless subscription services, each demanding its own piece of your entertainment budget. What if there was a better way to access a vast universe of content, live and on-demand, all in one place, and often for less? Enter IPTV.
IPTV, or Internet Protocol Television, is revolutionizing how we consume media. Instead of relying on traditional cable or satellite broadcasts, IPTV delivers television content over the internet. This means a more flexible, often more affordable, and incredibly diverse viewing experience. From live sports and international channels to a massive library of movies and TV shows on demand, IPTV puts you in control.
But with so many providers popping up, how do you sort the stellar from the subpar? That’s where we come in. We’ve meticulously researched and reviewed the top contenders to bring you the best 5 IPTV services available in 2024. Get ready to elevate your streaming game!
How We Chose the Best 5 IPTV Services
Selecting the “best” IPTV service isn’t just about the number of channels. It’s about a holistic viewing experience. Our rigorous evaluation process considered several critical factors to ensure we recommend only the cream of the crop.
Reliability and Uptime: Nothing’s worse than buffering during a crucial moment. We prioritized services with a proven track record of stable connections and minimal downtime. Content Variety and Channel Lineup: A great IPTV service offers a broad spectrum of content, from local favorites to international channels, sports, movies, and TV series, catering to diverse tastes. Picture Quality and Performance: High-definition streaming (HD, Full HD, 4K, and even 8K) is a must. We looked for services that consistently deliver crisp, clear visuals without lag. Device Compatibility: Whether you watch on a smart TV, smartphone, tablet, or streaming box, your chosen service should work seamlessly across your preferred devices. Pricing and Value: We weighed the cost against the features, content, and overall performance to identify services that offer genuine value for your money. Customer Support: Responsive and helpful customer service is essential for troubleshooting and ensuring a smooth experience. The Best 5 IPTV Services Reviewed for 2024
After extensive testing and analysis, here are our top picks for the best IPTV services in 2024, each offering unique strengths to enhance your entertainment.
PremIPTV: Premium Experience, Unmatched Reliability PremIPTV stands out as a top-tier provider for those seeking a premium, buffer-free streaming experience. With an emphasis on reliability and a vast selection, it’s designed for viewers who demand quality.
Key Features: Extensive channel lineup with thousands of live channels, including international, sports, and entertainment. Massive VOD (Video On Demand) library with movies and TV series updated regularly. Consistent 99.9% uptime, ensuring minimal interruptions. High-definition and 4K streaming options. Supports multiple devices, including Smart TVs, Android devices, Mag boxes, and more. Why PremIPTV Stands Out: PremIPTV excels in delivering a stable and high-quality stream, making it ideal for sports enthusiasts and those who can’t tolerate buffering. Their channel variety is impressive, covering almost every genre imaginable. It’s a fantastic option for a comprehensive IPTV service subscription.
IPTV8K: Crystal Clear 8K Streaming at Your Fingertips IPTV8K is a game-changer for those with 8K-compatible displays, pushing the boundaries of picture quality. If you want the sharpest images and most immersive viewing, this service is built for you.
Key Features: Pioneering 8K resolution streaming for select content, alongside comprehensive 4K and HD channels. Robust global server infrastructure for ultra-low latency streaming. Huge selection of live TV channels and an ever-growing VOD library. Support for a wide range of devices, ensuring compatibility with your existing setup. Why IPTV8K Stands Out: For early adopters of 8K technology, IPTV8K offers an unparalleled visual experience. Even if you’re not on 8K yet, their 4K content is superb, making it a future-proof choice for high-definition enthusiasts. The commitment to cutting-edge quality is evident in every stream.
8K IPTV: High-Definition Content for Every Viewer With a name that speaks to its quality, 8K IPTV (8kiptv.pro) focuses on delivering a premium, high-definition viewing experience across a vast array of content. It’s perfect for those who prioritize crisp visuals and a rich channel selection.
Key Features: Thousands of HD, Full HD, and 4K channels, with growing 8K support. Extensive VOD library, frequently updated with new releases and classic favorites. Reliable service with robust infrastructure to prevent buffering. User-friendly interface across various compatible devices. Dedicated customer support for seamless assistance. Why 8K IPTV Stands Out: This provider offers a fantastic balance of high-quality streaming and a broad content library. While its name highlights 8K, its strength lies in consistently delivering excellent HD and 4K content across all categories, ensuring a satisfying experience for all viewers.
IPTV GSE: User-Friendly Interface, Diverse Content IPTV GSE is well-regarded for its intuitive interface and compatibility with the popular GSE Smart IPTV player, making it an excellent choice for those who appreciate ease of use alongside a rich content offering.
Key Features: Optimized for the GSE Smart IPTV player, offering a seamless user experience. Wide range of live channels from various countries and genres. Regularly updated VOD section with a good mix of movies and series. Reliable streaming with minimal buffering, even during peak times. Flexible subscription plans to suit different needs. Why IPTV GSE Stands Out: If you’re already familiar with or prefer the GSE Smart IPTV app, this provider offers exceptional integration. Its diverse content and reliable service make it a strong contender for anyone looking for an accessible yet powerful IPTV solution.
IPTV: Affordable Entertainment, Extensive Library This provider (iptv.ml) offers a fantastic balance of affordability and a broad spectrum of content, making it an excellent entry point for those new to IPTV or looking for a budget-friendly option without compromising too much on selection.
Key Features: Cost-effective subscription plans. Thousands of live channels covering news, sports, entertainment, and international content. Solid VOD library that is frequently refreshed. Good compatibility with various streaming devices. Generally stable service with competitive uptime. Why IPTV Stands Out: For viewers prioritizing value, IPTV.ml delivers. It’s an accessible option that still provides a vast amount of content, proving that you don’t always need to spend a fortune for a good IPTV service subscription. Making the Right Choice: Factors to Consider Before Subscribing
While our top 5 list gives you a great starting point, the “best” IPTV service ultimately depends on your individual needs. Here’s what to think about before you commit:
Your Entertainment Needs: Are you a sports fanatic, a movie buff, or someone who loves international content? Review the channel lists carefully to ensure your must-haves are included. Budget Considerations: IPTV services offer a range of price points. Determine what you’re willing to spend monthly or annually, remembering that longer subscriptions often come with discounts. Trial Periods and Guarantees: Many reputable providers offer short trial periods or money-back guarantees. This is an excellent opportunity to test the service, assess its reliability, and check device compatibility before a long-term commitment. Don’t be afraid to try a few to find your perfect match. The Future of TV: Why IPTV is Here to Stay
The shift from traditional broadcast to internet-based content delivery is not just a trend; it’s the future. A report by MarketsandMarkets projects the IPTV market to grow from USD 72.3 billion in 2022 to USD 192.1 billion by 2027, at a Compound Annual Growth Rate (CAGR) of 21.6%. This exponential growth is driven by increasing internet penetration, the demand for personalized content, and the desire for more flexible, cost-effective viewing options. IPTV offers a level of customization and accessibility that traditional television simply can’t match, positioning it as a dominant force in the entertainment landscape for years to come.
Conclusion: Elevate Your Viewing Experience
Choosing the right IPTV service can unlock a world of entertainment, offering an unparalleled selection of live channels and on-demand content with the flexibility to watch what you want, when you want. Our top 5 picks — PremIPTV, IPTV8K, 8K IPTV, IPTV GSE, and IPTV.ml — represent the best in reliability, content, and value in 2024. By considering your specific needs and leveraging trial periods, you can find the perfect IPTV service subscription to transform your home entertainment. It’s time to cut the cord and embrace the future of television!
FAQ Section Q: What exactly is an IPTV service? A: IPTV (Internet Protocol Television) delivers TV content over internet protocol networks, rather than traditional terrestrial, satellite, or cable TV formats. It allows for live TV, on-demand content, and often time-shifted media like catch-up TV, offering more flexibility than conventional broadcasting.
Q: Is IPTV legal and safe to use? A: The legality of IPTV depends on the source. Legitimate IPTV services license their content, similar to Netflix or Hulu. However, some services illegally stream copyrighted content. Always choose reputable providers to ensure you’re using a legal and safe IPTV service subscription.
Q: What internet speed do I need for IPTV? A: For standard definition (SD), 5–10 Mbps is usually sufficient. For high-definition (HD) and 4K content, you’ll need at least 25 Mbps, with 50 Mbps or higher recommended for 4K and 8K streaming to ensure a smooth, buffer-free experience.
Q: Can I use IPTV on multiple devices? A: Most IPTV providers offer multi-device compatibility, allowing you to stream on smart TVs, smartphones, tablets, computers, and dedicated streaming boxes. The number of simultaneous streams often depends on your specific IPTV service subscription plan.
Q: How do I get started with an IPTV service? A: First, choose a reputable provider like those reviewed above. Then, typically, you’ll subscribe to a plan, install an IPTV app or use a compatible media player on your device, and enter the provided M3U URL or login credentials to access the content.
Top 5 Best IPTV Subscriptions for 2024 – tested and reviewed by our experts. By clicking on the product name in the list below, you can easily get updated prices, technical specs, and additional info about each product.
Profitez des vidéos et de la musique que vous aimez, mettez en ligne des contenus originaux, et partagez-les avec vos amis, vos proches et le monde entier.
Profitez des vidéos et de la musique que vous aimez, mettez en ligne des contenus originaux, et partagez-les avec vos amis, vos proches et le monde entier.
I’m a very amateur photographer that wants to capture memories as film instant prints and a few digital photos too. Would you recommend the Fujifilm Wide Evo that just came out? I currently own a Fujifilm mini 70 and all I need to do is buy new batteries for it and some film refills.
Should I just stick with my mini 70? Or does the Wide Evo have more to offer
Note: the cameras I want have to be used in the long run. I’m talking decades in the future of usability since I do not want to indulge in consumerism
This news — you know, the stuff that shows National Guard troops aren’t exactly happy to be expendable pieces in Trump revenge schemes — is unsurprising. No one signed up for this…
The Treasury Department told the House Oversight Committee it will turn over certain bank activity reports related to the panel's Jeffrey Epstein investigation, according to a letter shared with CNN.
"The Department of the Treasury (Treasury) plans to fully cooperate with the Committee and intends to provide all information responsive to your request in a timely manner and compliant with the law," a letter from the Treasury Department sent to the committee on Friday reads.
The bank records, known as Suspicious Activity Reports (SARs), include sensitive information and require a specific process for how they get shared. Such reports are not conclusive and do not necessarily indicate wrongdoing. Financial institutions file millions of suspicious activity reports each year, and few lead to law enforcement inquiries.
President Donald Trump's Federal Housing Finance Agency director Bill Pulte has been on a tear accusing various critics of the administration of mortgage fraud — most recently Federal Reserve governor Lisa Cook, whom he claimed improperly took out mo…
One night, a friend of mine went out for dinner with her husband and toddler. The toddler, who sometimes had trouble swallowing, choked on his food — and threw up, repeatedly, in the restaurant. People around them were laughing while my friend and her family were in distress, adding to their embarrassment. But that wasn’t the worst part, she told me. She thought someone might have been filming. What if a video of her child being sick went viral? What if the awful laughter at the restaurant never ended?
Social media has long been a game of roulette with fame at one end and public disgrace at the other. But if I am posting under my government name on Bluesky (or Facebook, or X, or Nextdoor, or whatever), at least I know I am rolling the dice on becoming the next unwitting bean dad, Brienne of Snarth, or Justine Sacco. Now all it takes to become the internet’s main character is to appear in public, where people film each other to perform the dual task of policing behavior and creating potential viral content.
Look, it’s easy to see why that Coldplay couple went viral. The exaggerated response to being on camera — and trying to duck an arena’s kiss cam — is funny. The couple is possibly cheating (immoral, loathed by TikTok) and Chris Martin (the man who knowingly married Gwyneth Paltrow and then consciously uncoupled!) gets a good dunk in. All someone had to do was identify them, and they had one of the world’s most powerful accelerants: the bad behavior of a CEO with one of his employees. It was perfect internet content.
The fact that it’s perfect internet content is also what encourages us to surveil each other. And the consequences of the funny internet video were very real. The CEO resigned. His former subordinate is getting a divorce, which I know because People and E! News reported on the filing as news. The humiliation didn’t end with the viral video — it’s still ongoing, and by writing about it, I am in some sense participating.
This is all possible because our society built a panopticon that any of us can use against any other at will. And while virality isn’t new, TikTok’s algorithm makes it easier than ever for videos to take off unexpectedly, because users don’t even have to share the video to make it go wide. You don’t even have to get caught on a kiss cam at a concert.
It is the work shortcut that dare not speak its name. A third of people do not tell their bosses about their use of AI tools amid fears their ability will be questioned if they do.
Research for the Guardian has revealed that only 13% of UK adults openly discuss their use of AI with senior staff at work and close to half think of it as a tool to help people who are not very good at their jobs to get by.
As per title, I visited a price comparison site this morning, and within a minute (I think less than 30 seconds) got a dodgy text to use 'their' site. I hadn't even chosen a category. This site takes peoples home addresses, phone numbers and other info.
Is the site hijacked/infected or is my phone?
The site is bonkers.ie a site in Ireland for comparing prices of broadband, electricity or TV etc. Link to screenshot of text as I can't upload on Lemmy because of VPN.
Militant, nationalistic, white supremacist violent extremism has increased in the United States. In fact, the number of far-right attacks continues to outpace all other types of terrorism and domestic violent extremism.
(Sorry, couldn’t find a working paywall remover. Anyone have a working one?)
There’s a “tremendous amount of disinformation” being shared online about the fatal shooting of Charlie Kirk, some of it coming from overseas, Utah Gov. Spencer Cox said. “What we’re seeing is our adversaries want violence,” he said Thursday night at a media briefing attended by FBI Director Kash Patel, who didn’t speak.
“We have bots from Russia, China, all over the world that are trying to instill disinformation and encourage violence,” Cox said, as he urged the public to take a break from social media.
We’re introducing a simple reminder that appears as a SCOOBE screen (Second Chance Out of Box Experience) to let you know your Microsoft subscription needs attention (for example, if a renewal payment didn’t go through). In just a few clicks, you can review and update your payment method and keep your subscription benefits uninterrupted.
Windows 11 may nag you now when your Microsoft 365 subscription expires
We’re introducing a simple reminder that appears as a SCOOBE screen (Second Chance Out of Box Experience) to let you know your Microsoft subscription needs attention (for example, if a renewal payment didn’t go through). In just a few clicks, you can review and update your payment method and keep your subscription benefits uninterrupted.
Hello Windows Insiders, today we are releasing Windows 11 Insider Preview Build 26220.6682 (KB5065782) to the Dev Channel for Windows Insiders on Windows 11, version 25H2.
Changes in Dev Channel bui
Today in Wilmington, Governor Stein joined small business owners and members of North Carolina’s TV and film industry to announce that three television-streaming series and four independent feature-length films have been approved for North Carolina F…
“All, Yesterday afternoon MESA received official notification from MSFC Center Director Pelfrey that MSFC will comply with Executive Order 14343 – Further Exclusions From the Federal Labor-Management Relations Program (link below). This may be the last email I am able to send to you in this fashion as one of your union representatives as MSFC is choosing to comply with the President’s determination that your jobs are primarily “intelligence, counterintelligence, investigatory, or national security” in nature. Therefore, MSFC will be canceling our labor contract, which was ratified by MESA membership and approved by NASA last year...
Some of you may – rightfully – be asking what [Marshall Engineers and Scientists Association] is doing about all this. We will still be here. We will continue to provide advice, assistance, and support – it will just have to be during your lunch break, after hours, or on weekends. We are training new stewards and building multiple committees to focus on various aspects of our representational duties – keeping you informed, helping organize local support networks, conducting surveys, advocating on your behalf to management and elected representatives, and coordinating with our partners in the North Alabama Area Labor Council (NAALC), the NASA Council of IFPTE Locals (NCIL), and the International Federation of Professional and Technical Engineers (IFPTE).
We’re introducing a simple reminder that appears as a SCOOBE screen (Second Chance Out of Box Experience) to let you know your Microsoft subscription needs attention (for example, if a renewal payment didn’t go through). In just a few clicks, you can review and update your payment method and keep your subscription benefits uninterrupted.
Hello Windows Insiders, today we are releasing Windows 11 Insider Preview Build 26220.6682 (KB5065782) to the Dev Channel for Windows Insiders on Windows 11, version 25H2.
Changes in Dev Channel bui
Following the assassination of conservative activist Charlie Kirk this week, educators across the country have found themselves facing swift termination or potential discipline after allegedly sharing opinions on social media about the killing.
The company behind the Proton Mail email service, Proton, describes itself as a “neutral and safe haven for your personal data, committed to defending your freedom.”
But last month, Proton disabled email accounts belonging to journalists reporting on security breaches of various South Korean government computer systems following a complaint by an unspecified cybersecurity agency. After a public outcry, and multiple weeks, the journalists’ accounts were eventually reinstated — but the reporters and editors involved still want answers on how and why Proton decided to shut down the accounts in the first place.
Martin Shelton, deputy director of digital security at the Freedom of the Press Foundation, highlighted that numerous newsrooms use Proton’s services as alternatives to something like Gmail “specifically to avoid situations like this,” pointing out that “While it’s good to see that Proton is reconsidering account suspensions, journalists are among the users who need these and similar tools most.” Newsrooms like The Intercept, the Boston Globe, and the Tampa Bay Times all rely on Proton Mail for emailed tip submissions.
Shelton noted that perhaps Proton should “prioritize responding to journalists about account suspensions privately, rather than when they go viral.”
On Reddit, Proton’s official account stated that “Proton did not knowingly block journalists’ email accounts” and that the “situation has unfortunately been blown out of proportion.” Proton did not respond to The Intercept’s request for comment.
The two journalists whose accounts were disabled were working on an article published in the August issue of the long-running hacker zine Phrack. The story described how a sophisticated hacking operation — what’s known in cybersecurity parlance as an APT, or advanced persistent threat — had wormed its way into a number of South Korean computer networks, including those of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and the military Defense Counterintelligence Command, or DCC.
The journalists, who published their story under the names Saber and cyb0rg, describe the hack as being consistent with the work of Kimsuky, a notorious North Korean state-backed APT sanctioned by the U.S. Treasury Department in 2023.
As they pieced the story together, emails viewed by The Intercept show that the authors followed cybersecurity best practices and conducted what’s known as responsible disclosure: notifying affected parties that a vulnerability has been discovered in their systems prior to publicizing the incident.
Saber and cyb0rg created a dedicated Proton Mail account to coordinate the responsible disclosures, then proceeded to notify the impacted parties, including the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and the DCC, and also notified South Korean cybersecurity organizations like the Korea Internet and Security Agency, and KrCERT/CC, the state-sponsored Computer Emergency Response Team. According to emails viewed by The Intercept, KrCERT wrote back to the authors, thanking them for their disclosure.
A note on cybersecurity jargon: CERTs are agencies consisting of cybersecurity experts specializing in dealing with and responding to security incidents. CERTs exist in over 70 countries — with some countries having multiple CERTs each specializing in a particular field such as the financial sector — and may be government-sponsored or private organizations. They adhere to a set of formal technical standards, such as being expected to react to reported cybersecurity threats and security incidents. A high-profile example of a CERT agency in the U.S. is the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Agency, which has recently been gutted by the Trump administration.
A week after the print issue of Phrack came out, and a few days before the digital version was released, Saber and cyb0rg found that the Proton account they had set up for the responsible disclosure notifications had been suspended. A day later, Saber discovered that his personal Proton Mail account had also been suspended. Phrack posted a timeline of the account suspensions at the top of the published article, and later highlighted the timeline in a viral social media post. Both accounts were suspended owing to an unspecified “potential policy violation,” according to screenshots of account login attempts reviewed by The Intercept.
The suspension notice instructed the authors to fill out Proton’s abuse appeals form if they believed the suspension was in error. Saber did so, and received a reply from a member of Proton Mail’s Abuse Team who went by the name Dante.
In an email viewed by The Intercept, Dante told Saber that their account “has been disabled as a result of a direct connection to an account that was taken down due to violations of our terms and conditions while being used in a malicious manner.” Dante also provided a link to Proton’s terms of service, going on to state, “We have clearly indicated that any account used for unauthorized activities, will be sanctioned accordingly.” The response concluded by stating, “We consider that allowing access to your account will cause further damage to our service, therefore we will keep the account suspended.”
On August 22, a Phrack editors reached out to Proton, writing that no hacked data was passed through the suspended email accounts, and asked if the account suspension incident could be deescalated. After receiving no response from Proton, the editor sent a follow-up email on September 6. Proton once again did not reply to the email.
On September 9, the official Phrack X account made a post asking Proton’s official account asking why Proton was “cancelling journalists and ghosting us,” adding: “need help calibrating your moral compass?” The post quickly went viral, garnering over 150,000 views.
Proton’s official account replied the following day, stating that Proton had been “alerted by a CERT that certain accounts were being misused by hackers in violation of Proton’s Terms of Service. This led to a cluster of accounts being disabled. Our team is now reviewing these cases individually to determine if any can be restored.” Proton then stated that they “stand with journalists” but “cannot see the content of accounts and therefore cannot always know when anti-abuse measures may inadvertently affect legitimate activism.”
Proton did not publicly specify which CERT had alerted them, and didn’t answer The Intercept’s request for the name of the specific CERT which had sent the alert. KrCERT also did not reply to The Intercept’s question about whether they were the CERT that had sent the alert to Proton.
Later in the day, Proton’s founder and CEO Andy Yen posted on X that the two accounts had been reinstated. Neither Yen nor Proton explained why the accounts had been reinstated, whether they had been found to not violate the terms of service after all, why had they been suspended in the first place, or why a member of the Proton Abuse Team reiterated that the accounts had violated the terms of service during Saber’s appeals process.
Phrack noted that the account suspensions created a “real impact to the author. The author was unable to answer media requests about the article.” The co-authors, Phrack pointed out, were also in the midst of the responsible disclosure process and working together with the various affected South Korean organizations to help fix their systems. “All this was denied and ruined by Proton,” Phrack stated.
Phrack editors said that the incident leaves them “concerned what this means to other whistleblowers or journalists. The community needs assurance that Proton does not disable accounts unless Proton has a court order or the crime (or ToS violation) is apparent.”
