Salta al contenuto principale


why won't Lemmy let me comment or post unless Idisconnecte from my vpn


That's it, I get an error message whenever I try to post or comment if I'm connected to my VPN, butnot trouble if I just get disconnected.
Does not fit the idea of decentralized social media I had, but overall I'm mainly curious as to the reason why it is so.
in reply to Dop

It might depend on the lemmy instance you are posting to (lemmy.ml) and/or where you have your account (lemmy.world), because I don’t think that this is built into the AP protocol.

I suspect at least one of these uses some kind of filtering mechanism that blocks VPN users, like cloudflare’s CDN.

Questa voce è stata modificata (7 mesi fa)
in reply to unlawfulbooger

btw, I think you may have mixed up the instances. The user is on .world and the post is on .ml

Other than that, you're probably correct

in reply to Dop

One of many reasons to change instances
Questa voce è stata modificata (7 mesi fa)
in reply to Blaze (he/him)

That's where I went when I left .world. 😀
in reply to 7U5K3N

Why did you leave .world, if you don't mind my asking, and just out of curiosity?
in reply to Alas Poor Erinaceus

Not OP but I left because of the proposed change in moderation policy to allow "free speech" that basically would negate the anti-hate-speech policy.
in reply to Alas Poor Erinaceus

Dbzer0 was a better fit for me.
I like the way it's ran.. just all around a better experience for me.
in reply to Dop

Get a free VPS from Oracle cloud in whatever region you want, run Wireguard on it. There, now you have a VPN that you control, and since it’s hosted by Oracle, and not a VPN company, there’s no way to “detect” it.
in reply to krnl386

Or better, run your own instance, rather than a VPN.
in reply to umami_wasabi

Yup, good point. One can run a private instance for “selfish” reasons.
in reply to krnl386

Like basically all cloud providers, Oracle publish their public-facing IP address ranges.

docs.oracle.com/en-us/iaas/Con…

Many services block these because, as you are pointing out, standing up VPN tunnel routing on a cloud instance is sort of trivial. Cloud providers publish these ranges specifically so anyone can block them easily. If lemmy.world is not blocking Oracle Cloud already, it's only because they just haven't come around to it.

in reply to krnl386

I assure you that's detectable. The VPN detector I know, classifies all cloud providers as VPN as a matter of course, because no normal user would be coming from a cloud network.
in reply to Dop

Because so many bad actors use VPNs for ban evasion or span sources, blocking the VPN endpoints from posting or commenting is a low hanging fruit way of dealing with some spam. This is Lemmy.World stance.

There are many others instances that work over VPNs so in the spirit of decentralization you can use another instance to access lemmy.world content.

in reply to HootinNHollerin

It's hosted in their servers. Dunno about the content licenses, if any.
in reply to HootinNHollerin

They host it, so they can do as they please.

Vote with your feet.

in reply to slazer2au

It also prevents normal people from using Lemmy at all...
in reply to Ulrich

lemmy.world is NOT "Lemmy"

Hell, during the great reddit migration, if I recall correctly, lemmy.world had to cap sign-ups.

in reply to MachineFab812

It is a massive portion of Lemmy. And it doesn't just stop people from signing up, it stops people from participating in any way.
Questa voce è stata modificata (7 mesi fa)
in reply to Ulrich

You yourself aren't even using a lemmy.world account. Your take on the matter is backwards and bizarre.
Unknown parent

lemmy - Collegamento all'originale
NOT_RICK_SANCHEZ
This is it! Instance blocks it.
in reply to NOT_RICK_SANCHEZ

.world is a fickle bitch in general. It would be good if more users and communities balanced out amongst other instances.
in reply to Dop

Aye good to know some instances block VPNs , didn’t know that. As a user from China who has to use a VPN always that would be problematic. Guys I got lucky with my instance.
in reply to Dop

I just reconnect and hope for an unflagged IP lol
in reply to Dop

Lemmy has nothing in its code that blocks VPNs. Unfortunately a lot of instances use cloudflare and other man-in-the-middle services that do block VPNs.
in reply to Dop

Don't use Lemmy.world server it is the regime front on fedi.
Unknown parent

lemmy - Collegamento all'originale
Moshpotatoes91
I left lemmy.world for these reasons. Haven't had any issues with lemmy.ml yet though 👍
Unknown parent

lemmy - Collegamento all'originale
ObsidianZed
I tried to switch, but I had an issue with dbzer0 not marking posts as read which didn't work out for me.
Unknown parent

lemmy - Collegamento all'originale
ObsidianZed
It's likely a bug with the app as I use Sync, though it only occurs with dbzer0, 1 of 3 of my accounts.