Salta al contenuto principale


If you stop thinking that Germany's response to anything Israel is about Holocaust guilt and instead about rewriting German history, you'd understand German politics better.

🧵 below and also hauntologies.net/p/germany-wan…

in reply to Elia Ayoub (he/him)

The overwhelming majority of antisemitic attacks on German soil are from the Far Right, but these are rendered illegible because it does not fit with the White supremacy that continues to define a lot of German politics.
in reply to Elia Ayoub (he/him)

Germany is invested in the notion that *because* they are responsible for the Holocaust, they are also *best suited* to understand what antisemitism is. The idea that antisemitism is 'our' problem is inconceivable to German politics today. It is much easier to scapegoat foreigners instead.
in reply to Elia Ayoub (he/him)

Add to that the redefining of antisemitism as opposing Israel's actions and you get a German state that is fine with prosecuting Jews and non-Jews alike in the name of 'fighting antisemitism.' The most mundane of pro-Palestine events are thus turned into an existential crisis for the state.
in reply to Elia Ayoub (he/him)

Germany has been cracking down on civil liberties to make sure that no nuance is allowed in public discourse. They have cheapened the Holocaust itself by proving that it can be used to silence opposition to an ongoing genocide.

reshared this

in reply to Elia Ayoub (he/him)

Germany's complicity in the Israeli genocide of Palestinians has nothing to do with its Holocaust guilt. It has everything to do with maintaining a sense of the past that allows them a way out of their role in the Holocaust. They want it to no longer be a German problem.

reshared this

in reply to Elia Ayoub (he/him)

By acting as if all one needs to do to atone for the Holocaust is to be pro-Israel one is essentially saying that the Holocaust is no longer a German problem, that they can atone for their crimes in Europe by backing a state in the Middle East committing genocide.
in reply to Elia Ayoub (he/him)

Incidentally, this is itself antisemitic. If they can erase the Holocaust by backing Israel, then were the European Jews they murdered in the Holocaust ever really European? Or were they always foreigners, waiting for a Jewish state in the Middle East to be created for them?
in reply to Elia Ayoub (he/him)

They can't have it both ways. If the Holocaust was wrong because *genocide is always wrong* then backing Israel's genocide is unjustifiable. If the Holocaust was wrong but also it allows Germany to displace their antisemitism problem unto 'foreigners', well that's quite convenient isn't it.
in reply to Elia Ayoub (he/him)

That way the Holocaust is no longer entirely rooted in European antisemitism and colonialism. It's a win-win for the German state: they get to displace their role in historical and modern antisemitism unto a population of 'foreigners' that have very little political capital in German politics.

reshared this

in reply to Elia Ayoub (he/him)

By doing so they get to both demonise the Other - an old German tradition - while also downplaying and erasing the very real rise of the neo-Nazi and fascist Far Right, some of whom include pro-Israel actors who are envious of Israel's ethnosupremacist state and wish to replicate it at home.
in reply to Elia Ayoub (he/him)

Since I published this two days ago there have been two new Germany updates:

1- Germany declared that Jewish Voice for a Just Peace (JS) are “foreign extremists”. bsky.app/profile/ayoub.bsky.so…

2- A groundbreaking report by Israeli journalist Itay Mashiach exposes how Germany’s antisemitism monitoring mechanisms are being exploited to stigmatize migrant communities, minimize the threat of the far-right, & delegitimize human rights activism. bsky.app/profile/yossibartal.b…

reshared this

in reply to Elia Ayoub (he/him)

Not only is Germany labeling an activist group comprised of German Jews “foreign extremists” - Tell me, is there some precedent of Germany categorizing Jews as foreigners? - but Jews are the ones doing the work to expose Germany's weaponization of antisemitism.

Let me know when any of this starts disgusting you like it disgusts me.

Here's an article version of the above hauntologies.net/p/germany-wan…

reshared this

in reply to Elia Ayoub (he/him)

this is a side note to the whole thread, but that statement about importing racism immediately reminded me of Australia's position during the Évian conference, where they said they won't help Jewish refugees "as we have no real racial problem, we are not desirous of importing one".
in reply to Elia Ayoub (he/him)

I fully agree with your points. Germany's position and actions in this are disgusting, and calling BDS and JS extremists is ludicrous.
That said, translating "auslandsbezogener Extremismus" as "foreign extremists" isn't quite accurate. It means "extremism that relates to foreign countries", so it says that the cause is foreign, not the people. There for sure is a questionable connotation with that as well, I just felt that the Twitter post you quoted was slightly misleading in that.
in reply to Elia Ayoub (he/him)

Israel is a giant Jewish Ghetto to send all the Jews that the world doesn’t want. It has always been a state created by and for antisemites to get rid of Jews and make it look like they care about us, while getting rid of us.
Zionism and the creation of the state of Israel is antisemitic appeasement.
This is why it is so fervently protected.
Questa voce è stata modificata (3 mesi fa)
in reply to Jo - pièce de résistance

@JoBlakely and yet from the very beginning Hitler antisemitism was always as well an antizionism, since in his mind jews were incabable of statehood and therefore would always be an “statedesolving” (“staatszersetzendes“) element that is needed to get rid of. A jewish state in existence would have contradicted that and even though there were plans of expelling jews from Europe, the big industrial and militarism effort was put into the annihilation of the Jews (the holocaust).

But there are antisemtic Zionists in your sense, like the former leader of Hezbollah, Nasrallah, who argued for every Jew to come to Israel, since it would be easier to kill them all there at once together, instead of the complicated hunt to find and kill them all over the world …

in reply to Elia Ayoub (he/him)

Yes, being an immigrant in this country and witnessing up close the overtly xenophobic sentiment grow hand-in-hand with actual literal Hitlerist Nazism, I no longer believe the Israel apologia was ever primarily motivated by the Holocaust or genocide guilt, like at all.

Germans support Israel because they are in favour of the ethnic cleansing. Unambiguously. They talk of Palestinians the same way colonizers have always excused genocide: Their culture is barbaric, they're violent, a danger to women and children, the land grab is legitimate because of this or that treatise, "right of return" is lazy people who want an easy life and aren't even real Palestinians etc. It's the exact same pretexts of the past 500 years. Israel is an European colonization project and Germans *endorse* that. They think cleansing the land of Arabs and replacing them with civilized people like us is inherently a good thing.

The Israeli narrative is beloved in Germany because it gives them a justification to finally come out about how they have always felt about immigrants. Remembrance culture was only ever a way to pretend Nazism isn't an ongoing movement, and the memory of the Holocaust was only ever a discursive tactic to centre themselves. Germans don't care about Jewish lives at all, or 1 in 4 wouldn't be pro-Nazi as of current polls; any Jewish individual who dares to defy Israel (and, consequently, defy the Germans) is quickly thrown to the wolves.

in reply to Elia Ayoub (he/him)

Some people like to call this kind of behaviour #psychozionism 👇

"Most frightening today is the sheer fury of Germany’s assertion that, as a country, it best and uniquely understands the lessons of its own murderous past, and the global future of its erstwhile victims. In every invocation of Germany’s unique position, historical responsibility comes to sound more and more like pride."
nplusonemag.com/online-only/on…

#Germany #Austria #zionism
#racism #fascism #antisemitism

in reply to Elia Ayoub (he/him)

Every time any country wants to blame one minority for hate crimes against another, that should set off everyone's spidey senses. It is just not true unless you believe that white Europeans are paragons of anti-racist virtue. Very, very not true.
in reply to Elia Ayoub (he/him)

So much rubbish in so few words. the 90s were called "Baseballschlägerjahre" because the skinheads used them to terrorise neighborhoods. In Rostock, a town which then nearly no immigranters lived in, we had one of the too many progromes in the 90s.
We had a group of well supported right wing terrorists called NSU. they murdered between 1998 and 2011. No immigrant was part of it.
And there are many more examples I can show.

#Merz either does not know, what he is talking about or simply a liar. However it may be: That is not something a German Chancellor should be able to say without somebody objecting him.

bpb.de/shop/zeitschriften/apuz…

de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ausschre…

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National…

#Merz
in reply to Elia Ayoub (he/him)

Stop guilt tripping yourself for past crimes of WW2 Germany and do the right thing with crimes against humanity TODAY. The Jews (Israel) are exterminating Palestinians TODAY and no one does anything out of fear of "antisemitism". There is NOTHING antisemitic for telling (ordering) them to stop killing civilians.
in reply to Elia Ayoub (he/him)

"The 'racism' problem exists because we have so many immigrants" is a great take.
in reply to Elia Ayoub (he/him)

yes, it is very convenient for germany forget the rich kids singing pop songs with nazi lyrics and doing sieg heils. Merz is lying and using the blankets of antisemitism to move towards facism.
in reply to Elia Ayoub (he/him)

Thanks for sharing this and your comments below. It is surprising the irony of Merz accusing migrants of racism. It is scaring when political leaders start accusing the foreigners of being the source of their own problems. I just copy here the original link in the image for context dw.com/en/germanys-merz-extrem…
Questa voce è stata modificata (3 mesi fa)
in reply to Elia Ayoub (he/him)

It is time for people in US, Europe (not UK) and Russia to admit than relocating Jews to Palestine was a terrible mistake and one more attempt not to fight antisemitism in these countries. After 80+ years it must be stated (as painful as it is than it is a painful experiment). Merz may offer Israel state some new territories around Dachau, Buchenwald. Auschwitz could become an Israel new colony since Poles complain about the difficulty to rebrand it as a Polish city. Same for Drancy
in reply to Elia Ayoub (he/him)

Das ist so dermaßen erbärmlich. Nicht für die #niemehrcducsu an sich, von da überrascht mich Nix mehr.

Aber für den doitschen #Kanzler. Meine Fresse.

in reply to Elia Ayoub (he/him)

Yup.
It’s pretty clear.
They can’t possibly be homegrown.
Blame the immigrants, as before.
in reply to Elia Ayoub (he/him)

Deutsche Welle has better reporting than many other news sources even though it is state owned lmao