I am planning to shut down this account and abandon social media for a while.
I have canceled myself to try to help as many as possible lately, and supported everyone against slanderous accusations directed at them.
That ended up with my account being limited on mastodon.social with no notice, no explanation and no appeal, while anonymous genocide denialists, trolls and nasty people who tried to halt fundraising for Gaza are still allowed to act under a blanket of absolute impunity.
I can't even communicate effectively with new accounts in need from Gaza if my profile is hidden on the main instance.
I'll keep cheering for @aral and @joynewacc from the sidelines, they're doing an amazing job, and I'll keep supporting accounts from Gaza, because it's the right thing to do.
Just not here, and away from the spotlights - also for my own safety.
I may be back one day, I don't know if on Nostr, or some other platform that has already taken into account the fact that the admin of the largest instance of a decentralized network can also be an asshole who has the power to cut you from your own network and those you're trying to help, even when you run your own instance.
Adieu.
manganiello.social/notice/Ayuc…
Mastodon
The original server operated by the Mastodon gGmbH non-profitMastodon hosted on mastodon.social
reshared this
Jones
in reply to Fabio Manganiello • • •Gorneman
in reply to Fabio Manganiello • • •Fabio Manganiello likes this.
Regendans
in reply to Fabio Manganiello • • •Please stay !!! This is an important moment in time.
And people can migrate away from mastodon dot social.
Fabio Manganiello
in reply to Regendans • • •@regendans thank you for your support ❤️
I wish that was the case…the ugly truth is that m.s has 3M users, it’s by far the largest player on the Fediverse, and people are unlikely to move out of there. They’ve already behaved like unaccountable jerks before, they got backlash from people urging the accounts there to move, but they’re still by far the largest instance.
This Fediverse thing is decentralized only in theory, if the admins of the largest instance can in a blink of an eye cut you off from 30% of all the Fediverse users…
Oblomov reshared this.
the esoteric programmer
in reply to Fabio Manganiello • • •the esoteric programmer
in reply to the esoteric programmer • • •Fabio Manganiello
in reply to the esoteric programmer • • •That’s 522/2367 followers in my case - or about 22% of my followers gone with that single instance gone.
Btw 22% is close to the total share of users that are on the main instance compared to the whole of the Fediverse - the law of big numbers is at it again.
A technology where a quarter of the users is on a single server can’t be called decentralized. Markets where a single company holds a quarter of the total share are usually considered monopolies/oligopolies. So far I tried to ignore the literal elephant in the room, but after seeing the consequences of their action to the visibility of my content I’ve decided that it can’t be ignored anymore. We’ve been repeating for years that mastodon.social is the Facebook of the Fediverse, with all the negative meanings that that implies, and that people should move out of it, but people are still on it and new accounts still register to it.
The server is mine, it runs in my home, but @Gargron has still a say on who I can reach out to. And if he decides to limit or suspend my account I still have to beg him to be able to communicate again effectively with those from Gaza who often ask me for help without following me and are overwhelmingly on the main instance.
I have to beg a single guy who has no clue of how the world works, and who bends repeatedly to Zionist pressures, not to limit my own account on my own server in my own home so that I can effectively support a campaign that is literally saving human lives.
This is humiliating and wrong on so many levels that I don’t want to have anything to do with this Fediverse shit anymore - despite having contributed to it.
Mastodon
Mastodon hosted on mastodon.socialOblomov reshared this.
Regendans
in reply to Fabio Manganiello • • •@Gargron @esoteric_programmer Your profile is limited in the sense that others will not immediately see your profile image and description. This does not matter for your current followers as far as I know. And for those who want to see your profile details, they can click to continue. Pretty bad but it is not like your account is defederated or suspended.
I've been active in the Fediverse since years and I've seen mastodon.social growing like a giant silo despite people complaining before it was so big. 😰
But for this injustice we should IMHO speak up (and not silence ourselves!), and get new people that we want to help to migrate to other instances. For example one of the Gaza people is on mastodon.social but also mastodon.scot
Fabio Manganiello
in reply to Regendans • • •@regendans @Gargron @esoteric_programmer
The problem is that those who don’t follow me won’t be able to see my replies to other people’s posts too.
It already happened a couple of times in the past 2 days.
I received requests for support from newly created accounts from Gaza who needed verification, but who were not following me, and they didn’t see my replies.
That’s a battle that I’ve been fighting for years, but I don’t see any change happen - the share of users on the main instance today is similar to that of 2-3 years ago.
And even Gaza Verified accounts are mostly being created on m.s, which obviously exposes them to the all-eggs-in-one-basket problem.
reshared this
Oblomov e Joe Vinegar reshared this.
the esoteric programmer
in reply to Fabio Manganiello • • •Fabio Manganiello
in reply to the esoteric programmer • • •@esoteric_programmer @Gargron @regendans you’re right, I tested it in zsh and not bash, which is a bit more strict about square brackets semantics 😅
Bash-compatible version:
the esoteric programmer
in reply to Fabio Manganiello • • •I tried that one, and I get
jq: error (at :1): Cannot index string with string "url"
the esoteric programmer
in reply to the esoteric programmer • • •ha! this error was hard to track, but I entered the url and the stuff manually, I get this:
$ curl -s social.stealthy.club/api/v1/ac…
{"error":"Unauthorized: token not supplied"}
So, I guess go to social is the problem, eh?
Fabio Manganiello
in reply to the esoteric programmer • • •yup, I just gave it a try and it looks like you’re on an instance that doesn’t allow unauthorized API calls.
I guess that the simplest way is probably to install toot, then:
(Also, the
id
in/api/v1/accounts/{id}/followers
is not your username but your user ID, that you can fetch via/api/v1/accounts/lookup?acct={handle}
)GitHub - ihabunek/toot: toot - Mastodon CLI & TUI
GitHubJoe Vinegar reshared this.
Regendans
in reply to the esoteric programmer • • •the esoteric programmer
in reply to Regendans • • •O yeah, I do know about the gts people, I'm in their matrix rooms 😛
But yeah, I did some calculations, and 21.27659574468085% of my followers are on there. I wish I knew how to do that math within the script itself, but anyway, I think that's acceptable risk. I dk about the other 2 or so people on my instance, however I might be defederating from mastodon.social soon enough, now that I know exactly what I got to lose.
Fabio Manganiello likes this.
Fabio Manganiello
in reply to the esoteric programmer • • •@esoteric_programmer @regendans @Gargron just keep in mind that by defederating m.s you’ll also lose access to most of the Gaza Verified accounts:
That’s the biggest problem here…m.s is notoriously hostile towards anti-genocide voices, it allows Zionist propaganda and genocide denialism to flow unimpeded, as well as threats and slander from anonymous accounts towards those who run humanitarian initatives (or towards genocide victims too), but it’s also the place where 80% of those accounts are.
This is a Stockholm syndrome problem.
And until @staff clarifies their stance I feel like those accounts must be moved to safer havens.
Xdej
in reply to Fabio Manganiello • • •Defending the rare gazaouis that moved out of mastodon.social is still a nice goal!
@aral @Gargron @joynewacc @esoteric_programmer @regendans
Fabio Manganiello
in reply to Xdej • • •@xdej @esoteric_programmer @regendans in normal conditions I wouldn’t mind. Last summer I even blocked the main instance for a few days because of its inaction against Zionist trolls throwing threats at me with impunity.
But these are not normal conditions. 80% of the accounts we’re helping on Gaza Verified are on the main instance. And the ones in the pipeline are basically all on the main instance.
By limiting my profile they limit the reach of the help I can give them.
Even if they are supporting Gaza Verified on paper (because of the backlash they’d get if they were to ostractize a very popular and transparent humanitarian campaign), they can still jeopardize it by limiting or suspending the accounts of top donors and volunteers - new accounts then can’t get the level of support they need, and posts about the initiative won’t be visible to most of the users.
I don’t think that this is just a problem about 22% vs. 100%. It’s a deeply moral problem of what kind of Fediverse we want to build, and how much do we want to call the admins of the main instance accountable for their actions.
Plus, as I said in other posts, this episode is just the tip of the iceberg. The pressures I have received against my involvement aren’t limited to this episode. It’s human to expect someone who has taken too much fire on the frontline to step back a little before planning the next move.
Joe Vinegar reshared this.
Gytis Repečka
in reply to Fabio Manganiello • • •It's like quiting use of e-mail because too many folks use Gmail... Please don't quit Fediverse - there are plenty of people on small instances and even single-user setups.
You already self-host, so those who want to block or mute you - can easily do that. And those who want to hear you - just as easily too.
Unless of course, for whatever reasons, you need metrics for your reach
But Fediverse was never about metrics, was it not?
Fabio Manganiello
in reply to Gytis Repečka • • •when you are involved in humanitarian efforts it’s also about reach - people from Gaza have overwhelmingly registered to the main instance.
Of course the average Fediverse user probably knows how to follow me even if Gargron decides to silence my profile. But non-tech folks in dire need who have just installed the Mastodon app on their phone, use the default instance without knowing what an instance is, and just try to shout out a cry for help, without knowing anything of how this platform works, won’t be able to see my replies.
This is not about metrics and reach, this is about a crime against humanity that @staff should be called accountable for.
Joe Vinegar reshared this.
John Breen
in reply to Fabio Manganiello • • •Fabio Manganiello
in reply to John Breen • • •@jab01701mid that's because you already follow me.
Limited profiles can be seen by those who already follow them, but not by anyone else - which also includes replies to other people's posts.
Jones
in reply to Fabio Manganiello • • •> That ended up with my account being limited on mastodon.social with no notice, no explanation and no appeal, while anonymous genocide denialists, trolls and nasty people who tried to halt fundraising for Gaza are still allowed to act under a blanket of absolute impunity.
For these reasons i ask @admin, the admins of the instance i'm writing from, if they can at least silence mastodon.social.
I just have the doubt that their policy only applies to their users, not to users of other instances or other instances, since that is not specified in the policy, but considering that this instance i'm writing from, todon.nl, doesn't accept "colonialism (incl. Zionism)" in posts by its users, todon.nl/about#en, it seems to me that silencing mastodon.social for such an infamy would be the very, very least they could do.
CC: @Gargron (mastodon CEO and maybe still one or the main admin of mastodon.social)
Todon.nl
Mastodon hosted on todon.nlJoe Vinegar reshared this.
Fabio Manganiello
in reply to Jones • • •@jones @admin @Gargron for as much as I (strongly) disagree with the way the main instance is managed and how transparent they are about their decisions, I feel like I must ask to hold on the horses before mass silencing/defederation.
The simple reason is that the vast majority of accounts from Gaza are currently registered on the main instance, and muting m.s means muting their voices too (or new voices that may come in and may not be heard if the instance is muted).
This is a very unfortunate case of Stockholm syndrome where the instance that persecutes the most outspoken critics of the genocide is also the one that hosts most of those victims…
reshared this
Jones e Joe Vinegar reshared this.
Jones
in reply to Fabio Manganiello • • •I agree. Anyway i'm glad i mentioned @Gargron in the hope he could do something about the infamy that is ongoing.
Fabio Manganiello likes this.
Jones
in reply to Jones • • •@admin
Obviously, @Gargron is saying nothing.
Fabio Manganiello
in reply to Jones • • •unfortunately they did, but via email.
They basically blamed me for block evasion, harassment, doxxing and legal threats.
Not the guys who blocked us just to keep lurking on our profiles and shamed us (and the victims from Gaza) on their timelines calling for blocks and defederation - behind our backs, without tagging us, and without even giving us a chance to respond.
Not the guys who kept throwing mud on Gaza Verified and called the victims scammers.
Not the guy who threatened to report me to my employer for antisemitism, and even left bad public comments about Booking saying “it employs a notorious antisemite like Fabio”. And when I asked for the details of that account because I wanted to proceed through legal means for defamation (because those comments, even though deleted by now, caused my HR to ask me questions) then it’s me throwing “legal threats”, rather than simply trying to leverage my rights as a citizen who has all the right to call accountable those who try to purposefully inflict permanent reputational damage.
These folks have not been limited (for years), but I have been limited.
Also, mentioning the Law of Return as a ground for colonialist expansion and calling Jews both at home and abroad to protest more, carrying both Israeli and Palestinian flags on the streets so they can’t be accused of antisemitism, is a ground for limitation or suspension on the main instance.
They are basically staring at our finger while our finger is pointing at a genocide.
After reading this, and after reading their staff bragging about the support that they’ve given to Gaza Verified, I feel like these folks have lost any inch of leftover credibility they could have in my eyes. mastodon.social is a crypto-Zionist instance that struggles to manage its own contradictions, and everybody onboard should leave that sinking ship. Starting from the accounts from Gaza currently exposed to regular harassment without anybody from @staff protecting them. Me and Aral can’t keep doing their work and expose ourselves on the gunfire of well-equipped armies of Zionist trolls. Either we do that, or we focus on helping people.
They can punish you even for quoting Omer Bartov on the NYT or Bertrand Russell if that doesn’t align with their sensitivities. And we’re supposed to care more about their sensitivies than our ability to reach out to people literally begging for food. Entitled privileged kids who live in their own fucking academic ivory tower and don’t even see a real-world emergency when you put it under their noses.
We are supposed to help the victims of an ongoing genocide, but not eradicate the ideological and political seeds that may lead to new occurrences of such acts of aggression.
mastodon.social is managed by morally bankrupt individuals who are accomplice in genocide and are actually obstructing humanitarian initiatives while bragging about them.
Mastodon
Mastodon hosted on mastodon.socialMastodon.social Staff
2025-10-06 22:43:35
reshared this
las_lallero e Jones reshared this.
Jones
in reply to Fabio Manganiello • • •@Gargron
i mention some accounts that i think may be interested in knowing about all this shit the mastodon.social admins have been doing and are doing
@guiscardo
@admin@stereodon.social
@gubi
@jops
@utentone
@admin@mastodon.bida.im
@samba
@lesion
@admin@mastodon.cisti.org
@rolery
@antanicus
@admin@puntarella.party
@kenobit
@ed
(admins of livellosegreto.it)
@admin
Joy
in reply to Fabio Manganiello • • •Y have all of my deepest sympathy, & respect. It takes immense courage & integrity to stand up for others, & what you’ve done by supporting us against slanderous attacks is the very definition of a true ally.❤️
Prioritize your safety & your peace. Take the time u need. The fight for what's right will always welcome you back, in whatever capacity and on whatever platform you choose. Until then, you can be sure that the impact of your work remains.
Fabio Manganiello likes this.
Joe Vinegar reshared this.
Fabio Manganiello
in reply to Joy • • •thank you so much for your support Joy, it means everything ❤️
As I said I’m not disappearing - you know where to find me whenever you need me 😀
I’m just taking a step back from the spotlights because of the pressure I’ve been exposed to - and this is not an easy decision either.
I still stand by your side and by the side of the people of Gaza and I will still give you all the support that you need.
I’ll just a step back from the spotlights though…
Joe Vinegar reshared this.
baskin 🇵🇸
in reply to Fabio Manganiello • • •Fabio Manganiello likes this.
Joe Vinegar reshared this.
Fabio Manganiello
in reply to baskin 🇵🇸 • • •@baskin than you so much for your support 😀
My issue isn’t much of finding a new instance - I’m self-hosted on an Akkoma server in my utilities room, I could simply create another account here or even spin up another domain.
My issue is with the sum of all the external pressures that have been applied - being limited on the main instance (on top of being already blocked by mastodon.art) is just the tip of the iceberg.
When too much pressure is applied you just need to take a break to heal and recover before thinking of the next steps.
Mastodon.ART
Mastodon hosted on mastodon.artJoe Vinegar reshared this.