Salta al contenuto principale


Today, we’re ready to show you the upcoming quote posts feature in more detail. We’ve put together a blog post with examples of how quote posts will work on Mastodon, ahead of early access on our own servers next week 💬 Full launch to come, in Mastodon v4.5

blog.joinmastodon.org/2025/09/…

in reply to Mastodon

We’ve thought carefully about building this feature, and we hope it broadens your use of Mastodon!

However, you're in control: if you don’t want your content to be quoted, you can find the setting to prevent future quotes of your content under Settings -> Preferences -> Other (in Mastodon 4.4).

in reply to Mastodon

There’s documentation available today, along with an FAQ. If you’re a developer, draft documentation is available as well.

Quote posting will be available on mastodon.online and mastodon.social next week! We will be listening to your feedback on our new feature.

docs.joinmastodon.org/user/quo…

Questa voce è stata modificata (2 giorni fa)

reshared this

in reply to Mastodon

is there a plan to have similar control over replies ? The quote post controls seem pretty handy. It would be very useful to limit replies to followers or no one
in reply to Dev

@dev you can already do that by limiting visibility to followers.
@Dev
in reply to kolya

@kolya sure, but it is a different use case to express something publicly that you don’t want strangers (or anyone) replying to
in reply to Dev

@dev if you want unidirectional communication, you have a lot of options. but that's not what a social network is for. it's not social.
@Dev
in reply to kolya

@kolya I’m not sure if you’ve used other social networks like twitter or bluesky, both of them have the feature and it is widely used.
in reply to Dev

@dev @kolya Genuinely curious as to what other use cases are there besides "expressing something publicly", and whether or not they're acknowledged on Twitter/X or Bluesky. Because it's also very much well known for promoting scandalous content without getting into trouble.
Questa voce è stata modificata (2 giorni fa)
in reply to Bùi Minh Đức

@duc @kolya I would simply like anything that I post which gets some traction filled with replies “well actually” or explaining my post to me. Or filling the replies with more unrelated misery about something bad that happened to me. Or having arguments.

The issue is never regular posts. It is important sometimes to indicate to people outside my circle that they don’t need to weigh in on something or I’m not asking for advice.

in reply to Dev

@dev @duc @kolya
Why do you want people outside your circle to read your posts, but to do not be able to say what they think about them?

What's the meaning?🤔

in reply to el Celio 🇪🇺 🇺🇦

@elCelio @dev @kolya Most people position Mastodon (and even they position themselves) as a social networking platform, but some others may associate it with the likes of Twitter/X, Threads, Bluesky, Tumblr etc. as a microblogging platform, aka a quicker alternative to maintaining a dedicated blogging website. Mastodon happens to be the most popular out of the platforms built on the ActivityPub protocol. For those people, they see they should have interaction control over the content.
in reply to Mastodon

Quick question that I'm not seeing in the FAQ or docs: when is something a `Quote` and when is something a `ShallowQuote`? In what cases should I expect each?
in reply to Tyler Fisher

@tylrfishr Quotes can be nested. The nested quote will be shallow to prevent recursion.
in reply to Mastodon

can we remove ourselves from quote toots on a case by case basis?
in reply to Mastodon

i don’t understand why this took so long.

the worries that this could be used to make negative comments about others post are completely out of reality, because this can also be achieved by posting it as a link or posting a screenshot.

on other platforms that is handled quite simply: if somebody does a repost that you don’t like, block the account and done.

Actually, then they still can post links or screenshots with negative comments because thats anyway completely unavoidable.

in reply to Lazy B0y

I guess It took so long, since this has been designed with a complete workflow of requesting an approval and stuff like that. You can see the whole FEP here: codeberg.org/fediverse/fep/src…

Other fediverse systems (FoundKey, Mitra, Pleroma, Threads, Friendica, Bridgy Fed, Hollo, Iceshrimp) already implemented another FEP: codeberg.org/fediverse/fep/src…

So we will have a situation with two concurring systems.

in reply to Michael 🇺🇦

@heluecht
thanks for the background info!

allowing reposts only with consent is impossible to enforce because one can always post a screenshot or the url.

@Mastodon

in reply to Lazy B0y

I just scanned through the thread. It is interesting to see that the opinion about this is really split in the Mastodon community. And yeah, you are totally right. There are multiple ways to circumvent the created restrictions.
in reply to Mastodon

That's great and I like the feature, but have you given thought to making quote-posts opt-in and not opt-out ? I really feel like opt-out is a mistake... You've made many things opt-in, like search discoverability, why not this ?
@MastodonEngineering @renchap
in reply to Célian Godefroid

@CelianGodefroid thanks for the positive words on the feature. We did consider opt-in/out, absolutely. Important note: defaults for post visibility and quotability only impact *future* posts. This means your past posts cannot be quoted. This is different from toggling profile discovery, which has an immediate impact. We're providing an early heads-up for people on these two servers (and anyone on 4.4.x elsewhere) that they can set their default visibility now, to prevent being quoted in future.
in reply to Mastodon

Thank you for your answer. I still feel like the default setting should have been to refuse quote posting, and letting people decide to opt-in later. Also prompt newly created accounts if they want to enable it or not. But it shouldn't have been activated by default like it was.
in reply to Mastodon

If my server is 4.4 and mastodon.social is 4.5 (pre release) will I still be able to stop someone from quote posting my posts on that server?

(edited to correct version numbers)

Questa voce è stata modificata (2 giorni fa)
in reply to Mastodon

You are going to turn this platform into the wasteland that is every other social media platform. Why am I even replying to you. Nobody ever listens anyway.
in reply to Mastodon

Why did you make this opt out instead of opt in? If someone I followed hadn't shared this post I never would have known about it. Opt-out is not transparent and is underhanded.
in reply to Mastodon

Can you add "following only" and "mutu only" ?

Or is their any technical issue with that ?

in reply to Mastodon

why don't add Following? it's better that people you follow to quote you because you have choose them than to let someone that you don't know (Followers) quote you
in reply to Mastodon

Unless you control who follows you "only your followers" is meaningless. "Only accounts you follow" or "only mutuals" would be preferable.
in reply to :blobcatverified2:

It will not break it, but we will still have got two different worlds. The older FEP e232 is created in a well thought way, so that on not supported servers you simply see some RE: https://server.example/objects/123 in the last line to indicate a quote.
in reply to Mastodon

I can't find the feature to moderate comments and/or review them before publishing them under each post I create. Could this be integrated in the future (as an additional feature) or is it already available? Thanks.
in reply to Mastodon

Cool. Can we get Markdown support (when composing) next?

Foncu 🐞🌹 reshared this.

in reply to Mastodon

What were the arguments for "quoting text above quoted post" over "quoting text below quoted post"? This is going to create a "dunk culture" on Mastodon with no upside beyond "works how it does on [toxic platforms that Mastodon positions itself as a better alternative to]".
What is your plan for dealing with the cultural problems this will create? "You can disable quotes, but it won't retroactively remove your post from a harasser's timeline" is bolting the door too late.

Oblomov reshared this.

in reply to Eugen Rochko

@Gargron Hmm not sure if i like that or not 😁 very ambivalent about that.

Usually i mute people because i am not interested or annoyed by their content. If other people share it, i'll see a comment out of context that probably makes no sense anymore

Something like "This is a good idea" and then you just don't see what idea is supposed to be good

in reply to Eugen Rochko

@Gargron @vamp898
Does hidden mean "a URL to the post, not embedded" or "like a content warning saying post from a user you've muted" or "just a blank space"
in reply to Mastodon

I'm so excited about this!

Curating news and articles and adding my own commentary/context is my main use case for a public social media presence.

in reply to Mastodon

Is posts going to have metrics showing how many people quoted that post. Is so are we able see those quotes?
in reply to Mastodon

The default is 'anyone' can. I would change your setting to 'followers only' and see what happens.
in reply to Mastodon

Call me an amateur psychologist, but I think putting the comment after the quote would've removed a lot of the potential for toxicity. It's a lot less fun to write "get a load of THIS guy" posts when you can't put your framing in before the quote.
in reply to Mastodon

Is it possible to both reply to an existing post and quote another post?

Useful whenever you want to point someone who asked a question towards another post with an answer.

Joe Vinegar reshared this.

in reply to Axel Rauschmayer

@rauschma Based on the current implementation (quoted post as a separate attribute and allowing the top-level post author to remove the post quote) I don't think so. Perhaps that can be another new feature or my assumption could be wrong 😀
in reply to Bùi Minh Đức

@duc @rauschma it is entirely possible; in the Web user interface, you will be able to do so by composing your reply and pressing the quote button on the post you want to quote: this won't dismiss your reply but instead attach the quote
in reply to Mastodon

Entweetification. I do not want quote toots, and will be disabling the feature as soon as it rolls out. Ugh.
Questa voce è stata modificata (2 giorni fa)
in reply to Mastodon

I'm curious just how many people who advocated for this feature even stuck around or even committed to this platform (or any AP platform).
Questa voce è stata modificata (2 giorni fa)
in reply to Mastodon

How controversial is this feature? As half the abuse I had on twitter came from quote posts. Its why I disabled them on bluesky.
in reply to Mastodon

Cool.
Now when will you allow longer posts, as numerous other sites - now including X - do?
The longer text can be hidden behind a click, if that would help.
in reply to Mastodon

i'm sorry. i refuse to believe that listening to music helps plants grow.
in reply to Mastodon

Please tell me that I block *seeing* quote posts by others? Quoting is truly one of the worst features of Twitter and I really don't want to see it in my feed.
in reply to Mastodon

> me any time @Mastodon improves their software in any way
Questa voce è stata modificata (1 giorno fa)
in reply to Mastodon

Why did you adopt opt-out as the default? Is it correct to understand that because of your previous blog post ("Bringing Quote Posts to Mastodon"), you changed to a social networking site where anyone is basically free to quote?
in reply to Mastodon

me quedo con duda si de momento solo se podrá citar desde la web o también se podrá desde la app oficial
in reply to Mastodon

Maybe this ought to be obvious, but how is a quote post different from a public reply?
in reply to Mastodon

Looks like some improvements have been made over the earlier "who can quote" controls — thank you 👍
in reply to Mastodon

1) What if someone quotes you, and then quickly blocks you? Will you still be able to remove your post from their quote?

2) Why is this feature opt out? Most people signed up here knowing (and wanting) that there is no quoting feature, so why not opt in? (Or at least a way stricter default setting for quoting?)

in reply to Mastodon

I thought we pretty much universally agreed that quoting is what invited a lot of trolling on x, instead of having to engage in meaningful discussion?
in reply to Mastodon

When I put a link to another Mastodon post in my post, will it automatically become a quote, if the conditions are met?
in reply to Mastodon

Nice implementation! Thanks for including the revocation functionality 👍
in reply to Mastodon

Love this. I will quote post this post as soon as possible!
in reply to Mastodon

You may sometimes wonder, ‘Why doesn't that work?’ but at first glance, it looks well implemented. Great. Thank you.

@DJGummikuh this is for you (and me) 😉