Some Friendica comments not making it through to Lemmy


2 of my recent Friendica comments (1 and 2) are not visible from Lemmy. In the case of the one published by a sopuli user, it is visible neitheir on Sopuli nor on lemmy.ml. Both are on the same community, but I managed to comment later on that community. Do you know what may have gone wrong?
in reply to Liwott

@Liwott I think I understand the problem. I am able to reply on lemmy with this personal account, but I cannot reply with my account @Informa Pirata (which is an "organization" type friendica account), probably because on lemmy he can only write a personal account. Take away a curiosity, is your liwott@nerdica.net account an organization account (or maybe a sandbox account that works the same way)?
in reply to Franc Mac

Thanks for all the testing 😀

My account is "personal soapbox". But my account doesn't seem to be fundamentally problematic for lemmy, as most of my messages go through. I just noticed two of them who didn't.

NB : of course for #Nerdica I see all your comments, even the one who doesn't appear on Lemmy

Unknown parent

lemmy - Collegamento all'originale

Nutomic

Can you tell me how to find the id of the create activity for these notes? Then i can check the server logs for errors.

By the way, i noticed that Friendica publicly lists all the users who liked or disliked a post. That is supposed to be private in Lemmy (only used to calculate the score).

in reply to Nutomic

I did four tests from four accounts I own, all from the same friendica instance (poliverso.org):
1) OK from a personal account: lemmy.ml/post/219638/comment/1…
2) OK from a personal "sandbox" account: lemmy.ml/post/219638/comment/1…
3) OK from a "news" account: lemmy.ml/post/219638/comment/1…

**4) NOK from an "organization" type account: poliverso.org/display/0477a01e…

It seems clear to me therefore that the problem lies in the fact that Lemmy accepts messages from the first three types, but not from an organization page.
I hazard a guess (but I'm not a technician): is it possible that the "organization" account type in friendica corresponds to a lemmy account type that is not compatible with the answers (perhaps it corresponds to the "community" lemmy account type)?

Questa voce è stata modificata (3 anni fa)
Unknown parent

friendica - Collegamento all'originale

Liwott

Hashtags seem to be the problem, at least that's what comes out from very simple tests I just ran :


This looks like pointless simple commenting, but the reason was very simple :
- tests 2, 3 and 6 were delivered to lemmy.ml instantaneously
- test 1, 4 and 5 are still underway, seemingly because
- 1 contains a hashtag
- 4 contained one, and editing it out didn't help
- 5 is a reply to 4

Hashtag seems to be the culprit


@Michael Vogel
cc : @Dessalines @nutomic